My parents kept my adoption a secret. At 47, I discovered a whole new family

Table of Contents

Growing up, holidays typically consisted of just the three of us at home: my mom, dad, and me. I would eat dinner at the table for the expected amount of time before heading to a friend's house to celebrate with them.

Family wasn't the central part of my life, unlike with some of my friends. Now, I'm not downplaying it - I truly did love my parents and we were pretty close. It's just that our family was relatively small in size. My mom was an only child, and my dad was not close to his brothers, who were both older than him.

After my mother passed away in 2005, my dad and I became incredibly close. We talked almost every day, even if our calls were brief - usually just a couple of minutes - to simply check in and see what he was having for dinner. We'd also text each other after every New York Rangers game, and he'd often join my wife, Jennifer, and me at her family's gatherings for holidays.

I confirmed that I was their child and discovered the sender was a cousin from my dad's side of the family. At that moment, I was really struggling with my dad's passing, so meeting someone related to him - to us - felt like a comforting place amidst my grief. We set up a phone call that only lasted for about 20 minutes, and we agreed to stay in touch. That wasn't exactly the warm reunion I had been looking forward to.

This conversation left me wondering if I might have other family members out there that I have a deeper connection with.

The results came up right away, but something was off at first glance: none of the first names or last names seemed familiar.

As a strange feeling came over me, I couldn't shake the feeling that my parents had a private side. They'd always had an unlisted phone number, and when ordering takeout, we'd use an alias, usually Matthews, which was a play on my middle name. I'd always assumed this was just one of their quirky habits, but now I wondered if it was a way to hide something more serious.

I decided to message my closest match on the site - we shared nearly 25% of our DNA. I crafted a message carefully, leaving it open for a few days to avoid appearing too eager. Within a few hours, I received a response from a woman named Anna. Her initial guess was that our connection ran through her father, who she'd never met. My mind started racing with possibilities: could Wally have an unknown son who was Anna's father, or was it possible that my father had a secret daughter as Anna's mother? I was convinced I'd cracked the code and that Anna was my niece, the secret my parents may have been hiding from me.

Before she was even born.

As I began to type a response, I deleted it and went back to re-read what she wrote, over and over, multiple times.

What if I was the baby she gave up for adoption?!

What if the people I call mom and dad aren't actually my parents?

The secret comes unraveled

Anna confirmed her mom, Kathy, had a son, and guessed he was born around January of 1972 (I was born in March of that year). This began our new working hypothesis, that I was indeed Anna’s brother.

I hemmed and hawed, suggesting it might be possible that my DNA results got mixed up with someone else's or that there was a mistake at the lab. Anna had already been using Ancestry.com, so I quickly ordered a kit from them to verify our results. Weeks went by, and our conversations continued while waiting for the results to come in, giving us the opportunity to learn even more about each other. I also spent some time re-examining the family records I had gathered from Wally's apartment the year before. Notably, there were no records of any possibility of adoption in them. It was also strange to me that there were no pictures of me as a newborn among them.

I dug through all the social media I could find from Anna's family and noticed striking similarities between photos of her cousins, Kathi, and me. At times the resemblance was almost identical.

After what felt like a lifetime of waiting, the test results finally came in, and our suspicions were finally put to rest: I was indeed Anna's brother.

In the 47 years of my life, why wasn't I ever informed about this? How was this information kept from me and why? Now that the secret about my mother has been exposed, I began to wonder: Who my real father actually was?

Anna's family remembered the relationship that led to Kathi's pregnancy years back. They speculated it was with a man named Jack who was a bartender on Long Island, New York, back in 1971.

I searched further to see if I could find any more clues. I turned to a relatively new cousin and asked if she had any information about Jack, given my limited knowledge of him. What she told me totally stunned me: not only is Jack alive and living in New York, but he's spent over 30 years working as an actor. I checked online at IMDB and couldn't believe my eyes. It turns out Jack is often cast to play characters, like bartenders, doormen, and taxi drivers, in movies, TV shows, and commercials.

I'd never met him before, but I'd seen his face countless times from shows like "The Sopranos," "The Americans," "Boardwalk Empire," and "Law and Order," and from movies such as "Men In Black," "The Yards," and "Requiem for A Dream." He had even made a New York Lottery commercial that used to run all the time during New York Rangers broadcasts, which were often happening when my family member was glued to the TV back home in New Jersey.

I eventually got hold of Jack's phone number through his brother, who I had also already connected with.

I dialed and a warm voice eagerly picked up. For the first time I was speaking to my actual father. There was no emotional overflow, just two grown men chatting with each other like strangers catching up at a bar. I filled him in on my background, where I lived, and he did the same. He'd been married twice and had seven other kids, which meant there were eight of us in total - and I was one of them. Only six weeks earlier I was an only child, but now my father was still alive and was a well-known actor.

In a matter of minutes, he brought up my mom, Kathi, and his past relationship with her. She was quite young and it was a casual encounter. Her parents convinced her to let me be adopted, a decision that must have been really tough for her. I talked about my adoptive parents, who I now realize were the true heroes of this story. I'll never know why they kept my adoption a secret, but I'm grateful for all they did for me.

Meeting my new family

A few weeks later, I went to Connecticut to see Anna and my local aunts, uncles, and cousins, which brought a mix of emotions for everyone involved. I had a strong feeling that I had been to this place before, and my Aunt Mimi's house, in particular, felt like a second home to me. After that trip, I called Jack to share all the details and we planned to meet in person at his house a few weeks later.

My wife and I drove for two hours from our home in New Jersey, and I kept an eye on the GPS as it kept cutting down our estimated time of arrival by the minute. When I pulled up to the house, I finally met my father in person for the first time (apart from seeing him on TV and in movies). I felt the same sense of warmth and acceptance I'd felt with Anna and her family when I met Jack and his wife, Margaret. We ended up having a few bottles of wine with the four of us together, just like old friends who hadn't seen each other in years. Not only were we related, but we also shared a lot of common interests, including our loves of music, film, and the culture of metropolitan New York.

In the five years since we met, I've stayed close to my new family and gotten to know my siblings. I've shared the happiness of family birthdays, the pain of loved ones passing away, and the excitement of family weddings that I had missed out on as a child.

On several occasions, I've successfully brought together the two sides of my family, advancing my story. I've built an extensive family. I've come to believe that my genetics have had an equally significant influence in shaping my characteristics and personality as has my environment. I'm reminded of this when I hear stories of my mother's captivating personality, or when I notice mannerisms similar to those of my father.

I've also discovered a newfound appreciation for my adoptive parents. For reasons still unknown, they chose to keep this secret even though they brought me a wonderful life that I might not have had otherwise.

I often find myself wondering what might have been if I'd known the truth sooner, wishfully thinking I could have connected with my mom, but I'm grateful for my new family and the lively joyful atmosphere that brought me happiness a long time ago.

This article was originally published on